Carmen Efferson, reportedly Stevie Wonder’s one-time fiancée, has filed a response to Wonder’s lawsuit seeking to remove her from his Hollywood Hills home, where she has lived rent-free since 1988, according to a filing obtained by Rolling Stone.
Wonder’s complaint was filed in Los Angeles Superior Court on October 22. It alleges that Efferson and the singer reached an oral agreement allowing her to live in the three-bedroom house rent-free. The complaint says representatives for Wonder attempted to enter the home three times in July for an inspection tied to a property insurance renewal, and that Efferson refused entry. According to the complaint, a lawyer later informed Efferson that the oral agreement had been revoked due to noncompliance and that she was being served an eviction notice with a move-out date of August 27, 2026. The lawsuit followed after that date passed without her leaving. Wonder is asking a judge to order Efferson removed from the property and to award damages of $600, the amount he says he owes due to a lapsed property insurance renewal.
Efferson’s response
In her filing, Efferson alleges breach of the warranty of habitability, claiming Wonder failed to maintain the property in conditions fit for living. She alleges conditions including a damp or leaking ceiling and walls, holes in the walls, floor and carpet, damaged window screens and plumbing, and dampness or mold.
Efferson asks the court to order Wonder to pay her attorney fees and make repairs, and to reduce the monthly rent to a “reasonable rental value” until the conditions are corrected. She also claims that she has paid rent and/or provided other nonmonetary consideration or services in exchange for the right to occupy the premises. She disputes the title to the property, claiming Wonder is “not the owner of the subject premises and therefore lacks standing” to evict her.
According to exhibits in the lawsuit, Efferson wrote to Wonder’s lawyer, David Huff, in response to a certified mail request for entry to the property: “I do not consent. Do not make any attempt to make any kind of contact with me.”
A lawyer for Wonder did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
See Stevie Wonder live
Upcoming Stevie Wonder events with tickets available:
- Nov 19, 2026 — Madison Square Garden, New York, New York · Get tickets
- Nov 21, 2026 — United Center, Chicago, Illinois · Get tickets
- Nov 23, 2026 — Capital One Arena, Washington, District Of Columbia · Get tickets
- Dec 8, 2026 — Fox Theatre – Detroit, Detroit, Michigan · Get tickets
- Dec 9, 2026 — Fox Theatre – Detroit, Detroit, Michigan · Get tickets
Tickets are sold by GetUrTix. Code GTIX20 takes 20% off the ticket price at checkout — no minimum, no expiry.
Source: Rolling Stone Music







